
Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York
Best for a quietly luxurious Midtown base with a signature indoor pool and dedicated La Mer spa access.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York is a Midtown luxury hotel built around Baccarat crystal with a refined French restaurant, an indoor pool, and a La Mer spa—best for travelers who want a quiet, polished luxury stay near MoMA and Fifth Avenue. The Knickerbocker Hotel is a landmark Beaux-Arts luxury property at Times Square with rooftop and meeting facilities—best for travelers who want to be in the center of the Broadway/Times Square action.
Updated · about 0.5 km apart

Best for a quietly luxurious Midtown base with a signature indoor pool and dedicated La Mer spa access.

Best for being in the middle of Times Square and Broadway with easy access to shows, restaurants, and a rooftop terrace.
When Baccarat wins: Choose Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York if you want a small, highly curated luxury stay with an indoor 55-foot pool, Spa de La Mer treatments that include pool access, and a refined French dining experience steps from MoMA and Fifth Avenue.
When The Knickerbocker wins: Choose The Knickerbocker Hotel if you want to be in the heart of Times Square/Broadway with larger room inventory, multiple on-site restaurants and bars, meeting space, and a rooftop terrace for skyline views.
Bottom line: Baccarat is a boutique, amenity-focused retreat for guests who prioritize spa, pool, and a quieter Midtown location near museums and shopping; The Knickerbocker is a larger, historic Times Square anchor suited to travelers who want immediate access to Broadway, rooftop views, and more on-site dining options.
| Category | Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York | The Knickerbocker Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small, refined luxury centered on crystal, French dining and spa | Historic Beaux-Arts luxury focused on Times Square and meetings |
| Location | 28 West 53rd Street — across from MoMA; near Rockefeller Center and Fifth Avenue | 6 Times Square — steps from Broadway and Times Square; near Bryant Park |
| Size (rooms) | 114 rooms and suites | 330 rooms |
| Star rating | 5-star | |
| Pool | Heated 55-foot indoor pool (La Piscine), guest-only; cabanas and whirlpool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Grand Salon (French) and The Bar (60-foot cocktail bar) — 2 main venues, plus terrace | 5 restaurants, 2 bars/lounges including Charlie Palmer Steak IV and rooftop terrace |
| Spa & wellness | Spa de La Mer with treatment rooms, steam room, sauna; spa treatments include pool access | Not published |
| Known for | Crystal-driven design, intimate luxury, La Piscine and La Mer spa | Historic Times Square landmark, rooftop terrace and meeting/banquet facilities |
| Family / age policy | All ages welcome; primary guest must be 21 to check in; spa facilities 18+ for treatments/lockers | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age listed as 21 (supplier note) |
| Parking & transport | Valet parking (fee); house car and airport transfers by arrangement; near subway | Self parking and valet (surcharges), limo/town car service; near subway and major attractions |
Baccarat sits on West 53rd across from MoMA and a short walk to Fifth Avenue and Rockefeller Center.
Choose Baccarat if you want museum- and shopping-oriented Midtown access with a quieter block presence.
The Knickerbocker places you directly in the Times Square/Broadway core with easy access to theaters and Bryant Park.
Choose The Knickerbocker for maximum proximity to theaters, nightlife, and Times Square energy.
Baccarat is a small property with 114 rooms and suites that emphasize refined materials and residential comfort.
Expect a boutique, design-forward room inventory at Baccarat with a focus on quiet luxury.
The Knickerbocker is larger (330 rooms) and geared to guests who want central location and a range of room sizes.
The Knickerbocker gives you more room inventory and options close to Times Square, useful for groups and event attendees.
Baccarat centers its food and drink around the Grand Salon (French) and The Bar for cocktails and Champagne.
Baccarat is best if you want a focused, upscale French dining and cocktail program in-house.
The Knickerbocker offers multiple on-site dining and bar options, including a notable steakhouse and rooftop service.
The Knickerbocker is a good choice if you want several on-site dining choices without leaving Times Square.
Baccarat’s signature amenity is La Piscine, a guest-only indoor heated pool with cabanas and a whirlpool.
If an indoor pool and integrated spa/pool access matter, Baccarat is clearly set up for that.
On-site pool information is not published for The Knickerbocker in the supplier listing.
The Knickerbocker’s rooftop is a signature amenity; pool availability is not published and should be confirmed directly.
Baccarat focuses on spa and fitness with Spa de La Mer and a 24-hour fitness studio.
Choose Baccarat for a structured spa program and 24-hour fitness in a quieter Midtown setting.
The Knickerbocker offers 24-hour front desk service, fitness facilities, rooftop nightlife options, and meeting spaces.
The Knickerbocker is a practical pick for guests who want rooftop nightlife, meetings, and direct Broadway access.

Baccarat — La Piscine plus Spa de La Mer treatments that include pool access.

The Knickerbocker — located at 6 Times Square, steps from Broadway and Times Square.

The Knickerbocker — five restaurants and two bars, including a rooftop terrace and steakhouse.

Baccarat — smaller property (114 rooms) and a calm Midtown location across from MoMA.
The Knickerbocker is closer to Times Square and Broadway theatres; Baccarat is walkable but a bit farther.
Baccarat has an on-site heated indoor pool (La Piscine) and Spa de La Mer. The Knickerbocker’s supplier listing does not publish an on-site pool or a dedicated on-site spa.
Baccarat is directly across from MoMA and steps from Fifth Avenue, making it better suited for museum and shopping access with a quieter block presence.
Yes. The Knickerbocker lists about 2,200 sq ft of conference/meeting space; Baccarat also offers event venues like the Grand Salon and Petit Salon (smaller capacities).
Explore how Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·