
Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York
Best for travelers who want formal, refined luxury, a signature French restaurant and a spa with dedicated pool access.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York is a polished, five-star Midtown address known for French dining, crystal-led design and a dedicated La Mer spa. 1 Hotel Central Park is a five-star eco-luxury lifestyle hotel near Central Park for travelers who prioritize sustainable design and locally sourced dining; read on if you’re choosing between formal old-world luxury and contemporary sustainable style.
Updated

Best for travelers who want formal, refined luxury, a signature French restaurant and a spa with dedicated pool access.

Best for eco-conscious guests looking for modern, nature-forward design, locally sourced food and close access to Central Park.
When Baccarat wins: Choose Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York if you want a more formal, highly curated luxury stay — French dining, a 55-foot indoor pool (La Piscine) and Spa de La Mer set a classic, service-forward tone.
When 1 Hotel Central Park wins: Choose 1 Hotel Central Park if sustainability, natural-material interiors and a lifestyle atmosphere near Central Park matter more than formal dining rituals and traditional luxury finishes.
Bottom line: Both hotels put Manhattan attractions and Central Park within easy reach; pick Baccarat for classic, service-led luxury and spa access, or 1 Hotel Central Park for a modern, eco-focused alternative.
| Category | Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York | 1 Hotel Central Park |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Refined, formal luxury with crystal and French influences | Contemporary eco-luxury lifestyle, natural materials and plant-based touches |
| Location | 28 West 53rd Street — directly across from MoMA; steps to Rockefeller Center and Fifth Avenue | 1414 Avenue of the Americas — a short walk to Central Park, Carnegie Hall and MoMA |
| Size (rooms) | 114 rooms and suites | 229 guestrooms |
| Minimum check-in age | 21 to check in | 18 to check in (supplier listing) |
| Pools | La Piscine — heated 55-foot indoor pool with whirlpool; guest-only access | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Grand Salon (French) and The Bar (60-foot cocktail bar, Champagne focus) | Jams Cafe (restaurant) plus an on-site coffee shop/cafe and bar/lounge |
| Spa & wellness | Spa de La Mer with treatment rooms, steam room, sauna; spa treatments include pool access | Health or beauty spa nearby (supplier listing); on-site full spa details not published |
| Sustainability & local sourcing | Some eco-conscious dining practices and reduced single-use plastics are listed | Extensive sustainability measures: locally sourced food (80%+), no single-use plastic water bottles, recycling, compostable items, guest education on local ecosystems |
| Accessibility & family features | Wheelchair accessible common areas; children are allowed though pool supervision rules apply | Wheelchair accessible (may have limitations); accessible path, visual alarms and assistive devices available |
| Typical traveler | Guests seeking formal service, fine dining and a signature luxury spa | Guests who prioritize sustainability, modern design and proximity to green space |
Baccarat sits on West 53rd Street directly across from MoMA and a few minutes’ walk from Rockefeller Center and Fifth Avenue.
Choose Baccarat if you want immediate access to MoMA and Midtown’s cultural landmarks.
1 Hotel Central Park sits on Avenue of the Americas within easy walking distance of Central Park, Carnegie Hall and MoMA.
Choose 1 Hotel Central Park if proximity to Central Park and a nature-forward neighborhood feel matter.
Baccarat has 114 rooms and suites presented with formal, refined design.
Baccarat’s smaller room count supports a highly curated, boutique luxury stay.
1 Hotel Central Park offers 229 guestrooms across a variety of alcove, studio, city- and park-view room types.
1 Hotel Central Park provides a broader range of room types and more overall inventory.
Baccarat centers dining on the Grand Salon’s French menu and a Champagne-forward Bar.
If formal French dining and Champagne service are priorities, Baccarat is the stronger pick.
1 Hotel Central Park emphasizes local sourcing and a single main restaurant plus a cafe.
Choose 1 Hotel Central Park for informal dining with a sustainability and locally-sourced focus.
Baccarat’s signature amenity is La Piscine, the indoor heated pool that’s integrated with the spa.
For an indoor-pool experience tied to a high-end spa, Baccarat is the clear choice.
1 Hotel Central Park highlights lifestyle and nature-oriented features; specific on-site pool details are not published in the supplier listing.
1 Hotel Central Park focuses more on sustainable, nature-driven design than on a published indoor pool amenity.
Baccarat provides a full-service Spa de La Mer and a formal bar/restaurant program for evening plans.
Pick Baccarat for structured wellness treatments and a formal evening atmosphere.
1 Hotel Central Park emphasizes 24-hour fitness and casual social spaces aligned with its lifestyle brand.
1 Hotel Central Park suits guests who prefer informal social spaces and a wellness-minded environment.

Baccarat — Grand Salon and The Bar offer French cuisine, Afternoon Tea and a celebrated Champagne program.

1 Hotel Central Park — extensive sustainability measures and 80%+ locally sourced food set it apart.

Baccarat — Spa de La Mer includes treatment rooms plus access to La Piscine and pool cabanas.

1 Hotel Central Park — very short walk to Central Park and lifestyle design tailored to that location.
1 Hotel Central Park lists Central Park at 0.1 km / 0.1 mi; Baccarat is also walkable to Central Park (about an 8-minute walk per hotel materials).
Baccarat has La Piscine (a heated 55-foot indoor pool) and Spa de La Mer with treatment rooms and steam/sauna; 1 Hotel Central Park’s supplier listing does not publish an on-site pool and lists a nearby health/beauty spa rather than a dedicated on-site La Mer–style facility.
Yes — 1 Hotel Central Park emphasizes sustainability and local sourcing throughout its operations; Baccarat lists eco-conscious dining practices, but its positioning is classic luxury rather than an eco-lifestyle brand.
Baccarat — the Grand Salon and The Bar have dress expectations and a more formal dining and cocktail scene compared with 1 Hotel Central Park’s casual cafe and bar.
Explore how Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·